Skip to content

Learn

Stoicism, as it was actually practiced

Not a summary of the philosophy. The exercises the Stoics ran on themselves daily, the people who wrote them down, and an honest account of which famous quotations are not theirs at all.

Caspar David Friedrich, Wanderer above the Sea of Fog, 1818
Caspar David Friedrich, Wanderer above the Sea of Fog, 1818

Start here3 pieces

Three pieces that carry most of the weight. If you read nothing else, read these.

Sources and attribution17 pieces

A great deal of what circulates as Stoic wisdom is not. This is the part of the site that checks.

The Stoic quotes that are not Stoic

Quotations credited to Marcus Aurelius, Seneca, Epictetus and others that belong to a screenwriter, a songwriter, Voltaire, Kant and Eckhart Tolle. Found by auditing our own library.

One in four top "Stoic quotes" pages publishes a fake

We read the top results for ten ordinary searches. Of 144 pages, 38 present a documented misattribution as genuine. Method, numbers and the full dataset.

Check a Stoic quote

Paste a line attributed to Marcus Aurelius, Seneca or Epictetus and find out whether it is theirs. Free, runs in your browser, nothing is sent anywhere.

Stoic quotes, with sources

Six themed collections — death, perception, anxiety, discipline, character, other people — every passage cited to a book and a chapter.

Did Marcus Aurelius say "what we do in life echoes in eternity"?

No. It is from Gladiator, and Marcus argued the opposite: that being remembered is worthless and oblivion comes fast.

Did Aristotle say "we are what we repeatedly do"?

No. The sentence is Will Durant’s, from 1926. Unusually for a misquote it is a good summary of Aristotle, which is why it has been impossible to dislodge.

Did Epictetus say "it’s not what happens to you, but how you react"?

The idea is his, the sentence is not. A paraphrase of Enchiridion 5 that moved the work from judgment to reaction, and threw away the best part of the passage.

Who said "be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle"?

A Scottish minister in 1897, and he wrote "be pitiful". A century of anonymous editing sanded off every marker of its date, which is how it ended up credited to Seneca.

Did Socrates say "the secret of change is to focus all your energy"?

A character called Socrates did, in a 1980 novel. The real one wrote nothing at all, which is worth remembering every time a tidy aphorism arrives with his name on it.

Did Seneca say "luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity"?

No. It is an American saying, printed unsigned in 1912 and in its modern wording in a 1928 loan-company ad. Seneca’s name arrived around 1999.

Did Marcus Aurelius say "the obstacle is the way"?

The idea is his, Meditations V.20. The five words are the title of Ryan Holiday’s 2014 book, and the original is about difficult people.

Did Marcus Aurelius say "everything we hear is an opinion"?

No translation contains it. It rewrites two short lines into something close to the opposite of Stoicism.

Did Seneca say "fortune favours the bold"?

Virgil wrote it, from an older Latin proverb. Seneca quotes it once, and his own view of fortune was the reverse: it tests the brave.

Did Socrates say "know thyself"?

He quoted it, and said so. It was carved at the Temple of Apollo at Delphi, and the ancients could not agree who first said it.

Did Socrates say "I know that I know nothing"?

Not in Plato. Socrates says something narrower and more useful; the slogan is Cicero’s, three centuries later.

Who said "everything in moderation, including moderation"?

A 1920s joke about an ancient maxim. Not Marcus Aurelius, and not Wilde, Twain or Julia Child either.

Who said "a gem cannot be polished without friction"?

Neither Seneca nor Confucius. The earliest printing we found is a chapter title in a Victorian novel set in China.

The exercises7 pieces

What the Stoics actually did, daily, and how to run the same drills without abandoning them by February.

What people get wrong2 pieces

The two misreadings that do the most damage, both of them widespread.

When it is hard2 pieces

The Stoics wrote at length about anger and about grief, and were more honest about both than their reputation suggests.

Neighbouring traditions2 pieces

Where Stoicism genuinely overlaps with something else, and where the comparison is usually made badly.

Which book, which translation4 pieces

Four of the five surviving sources are worth your time. Knowing which edition to buy matters more than people expect.

The Stoics and their books3 pieces

The voices behind the practice, and the translations worth actually owning.

Marcus turns all of this into a daily practice for iOS: a morning preparation, a daily reading, and a structured evening examination.

Explore the app →